The talented Mr. Madoff…Wall Street Journal, Ruth Madoff, White Collar Crimes
According to NY Times reports, Mr. Madoff expressed remorse for having hurt thousands of people. He asked for 12 years in prison, which allows him to leave at the ripe age of 83. The judge Denny Chin gave him 150 years. Let’s all toast to Judge Chin!
There will be Madoff-type people anywhere we go, and in any tier of society. That’s an inescapable fact. But my question is: where were the regulators and employees? As someone who’s been looking for a job and evaluating her own qualifications every day, I find it hard to believe that someone who is talented enough to work at one of the world’s largest (albeit fraudulent) investment firms was so naive and oblivious that they couldn’t smell something fishy going on right under their nose! Did they literally believe that their investments were yielding double-digit returns for 20 straight years? Anyone with a shred of common sense should know that such a feat is not possible. And if they did know…should they be prosecuted as an accomplice? This is a lose-lose situation for all involved…either you are too dumb or you are a criminal.
And of course there’s the SEC…where were they for the past 20 years? All the smart and qualified folks at the SEC should be very fearful of their jobs because they have lost all credibility in the eyes of the US citizens. We need a new set of regulators with a new world view. We need to replace the SEC altogether! Clearly they either lack the skills or the moral compass to sniff out the largest and longest Ponzi scheme in history! Earlier I posted a blog about how our media is so focused on politicians’ affairs, sex scandals, and what they’re wearing than their performance in office. Well here’s another great example of that. Not only did the SEC mess up the subprime mortgage system, they also messed up the credit system and Wall Street. Wall Street is like a kid who had great genes and great potential, but due to negligent parents and bad play buddies, grew up to be failure and disgrace. I believe it still has those same great genes and potential, but it needs some foster parents and some new friends. Perhaps a new neighborhood would be good too…I recommend Iowa or Kansas.
Let us forget about Michelle Obama’s dresses and Iran’s political turmoil. We need to straighten up our own backyard before straightening out others’. Sentencing after the fact is not enough. It’s like dieting: you have to prevent from getting fat, rather than get fat and then try to lose it. We are simply not demanding enough of our independent regulators to do a better job on a daily basis. Where’s the media in exposing those incompetent regulators? Where’s the media in exposing Madoff’s office accomplices who saw the fake numbers and didn’t utter a word?
Here’s a take-home lesson for all of us: To maintain our integrity, we must not only do the right thing ourselves, but we must make sure that any observed wrongdoing is also dealt with appropriately. We must actively prevent another Kitty Genovese, or another Bernie Madoff.